What’s happened to social mobility?

This blog has sprung out of a fascinating conversation which I enjoyed on Facebook a few days ago. Danuta Kean was considering the lack of opportunities for working class, especially coloured working class actors on our stage. A director she interviewed had said. ‘The privileged pay lip service to diversity but keep everything at base level so everything remains intact.’ It provoked a lively exchange and many very sensible things were said. Amanda Craig pointed out that ‘It’s no use being sentimental or cynical about the problem.  The only duty is to see the truth about each individual as circumstances allow.’ It made me remember this picture, two sets of children of a similar age but with entirely different outlook and prospects. The Eaton boys who naturally expect to go on to Oxbridge and then into Government, the working class boys who expect very little.

The truth is that as we are all formed by our upbringing and education that we receive and consequently the way we behave and the opinions we hold have very deep, social roots. Education has always been a means of social control. When I was young a very small proportion of state educated children got to grammar school via the 11+, in London it was 20%, in South Wales 25%, in West Sussex only 11%. The children who failed the 11+ had lost their chance in life and knew it. At the end of the World War 2 our new government was determined to alter this and brought in comprehensive schools believing that all children should be given the chance to develop as many talents and skills as they could and that none should be thrown on the scrap heap at 11. There were many who fought the idea tooth and nail, but many more – like me – who backed it and did everything we could to bring it about and make it a success. Now sadly the clock is being put back.

Education is now largely about taking examinations. There is very little time for the children to learn through the joys of play, like these little ones below.

Many of our children get to university, achieve a degree and then find that there is no work suitable for them. Many end up stacking shelves in Tesco’s or serving in other shops, the increase in graduates has not been planned for or thought through.

And in the meantime, the rich have become steadily more and more obscenely wealthy and more and more determined to preserve the status quo which serves them so well. Sir Philip Green who inherited his family business at the age of 12, has just thrown 11,000 of his workers out of work and left British Home Stores with a pension deficit of £571 million, nevertheless collecting £586 million in dividends, rental payments and interest on loans for himself. Social extremes couldn’t be more clearly indicated then by facts like these.


2 thoughts on “What’s happened to social mobility?

  1. Dear friend Beryl:
    According to Forbes.com, known for their lists on wealth: “The wealthiest Americans donate 1.3 percent of their income; the poorest, 3.2 percent. What’s up with that?” The myth into which our US leaders bought and tried to reassure the middleclass and poor people is that the very rich will make sure no one goes hungry in America, I think the first tangible in-your-face promise to be broken was the federal subsidy on milk for school children. During those wonderful “Reagan years” a childsize carton of milk increased from 3 cents (!!!!) to 25 cents. Many people had to pass up milk. Just another unhappy thought about classes. We paid for our kids’ milk buying by the gallon and using a thermos for each child. No, we were able to afford this, but knowing that even that basic staple was gone for many was very, very sad. Best, Mary Latela


  2. It seems very sad to me that the American people have been persuaded to forget the first principles of the Founding Fathers, that ‘all men are created equal’. We all need to learn how to recognise propaganda for the public lie it invariably
    is and return to first principles. God Bless!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s